Editor’s note: I couldn’t make it through another Six Feet Under album, let alone a Six Feet Under covers album, so I decided to hand this one off to our good friend Matt.
Chris’ Review:
If you were worried (like me) about the world’s supply of cover albums running low, give thanks to Six Feet Under and Metal Blade for issuing their third (third!!) edition of death metal versions of “Graveyard Classics.” I know I’ve been railing for years to anyone that would listen, “There is so much great metal and punk from the 1980’s, and nobody knows about it! Nobody’s marketing it! There’s a gold mine waiting to be discovered and respectfully elevated to its honorable status, and you’re all walking around like zombies controlled by the “new music” piping through you ear buds. Wake up!” Finally we have friends at Metal Blade that ‘get it’ and assigned a talented, young group of death metal musicians to show today’s metal fans what they’re missing.
Ok, I just listened to Graveyard Classics III, and I need retract everything written above. As a collection, the album is a sack of crap. A couple tracks are interesting, but have no chance at redeeming the rotting, audio turds that should have never been unearthed from the cesspit in which they festered. (Hey, writing death metal is fun!)
There’s almost no theme to the album, so I’m going to have to break it down for you track-by-track:
The opening cover of Mercyful Fate’s “A Dangerous Meeting” reminds you of how good Mercyful Fate’s songs are, but does not make you want to listen to Six Feet Under any more. Most decent 80’s metal songs sound tougher when recorded in a modern production style, but that’s a tribute to affordable studio electronics, not the band. The same could be said about most the tracks on here.
The first Canadian import comes from the re-discovered Anvil. “Metal on Metal” sucked then, sucks now.
The next two tracks are from Slayer and Metallica. These tracks are decent, but how could a death metal band of any skill screw up a classic thrash track? It’s like congratulating an asshole on being an asshole. It should just come natural.
Our next Canadian clunker comes via Bachman Turner Overdrive. Seriously? See “Metal on Metal,” above.
Now honestly, without sarcasm, I did kind of dig this version of Van Halen’s “On Fire.” VH albums are barely listenable to me, but a competent, metallic version of one of their faster songs will make you nod your head. Barnes’ ‘grandma’ vocals ruin it, though.
This Exciter song sure sucks. Something about it sucks extra hard, but I can’t put my finger on it. What could it be? Oh, here it is! Exciter is Canadian. See above. If they move the Buffalo Bills to Toronto, one of the conditions should be that Toronto also has to take Chris Barnes.
Nothing says ‘eighties’ like Twisted Sister. And nothing says “Six Feet Under is fucking with us,” like Chris Barnes growling, “He’s gonna kick your ass!” at the end of this track.
This cover of the Ramones’ “Psychotherapy” makes it really hard to convince non-metal fans that death metal is not a joke.
Finally we have the album closer, a closet classic from the 90’s, actually, Prong’s “Snap Your Fingers, Snap Your Neck.” Any fan of Headbanger’s Ball of a certain era remembers this song (I’m one of them.) Checking back to Prong’s Cleansing album, these guys sound like nu metal before it was nu. I’m not sure Prong ever received the respect that a band on the bleeding edge of a new style deserves, and I’m not sure this shitty cover is going to help with that.
In summary, this cover album goes as most cover albums go. It feels more like an attempt to milk some extra dollars from the fans, and doesn’t do the covered or the coverers much justice. I have an album of Black Sabbath songs played on sitars that’s just about the same thing; I’ve listened to it once.
Crirs’ Rating:
King says: “I’ve got to start being more careful about who I give my publishing rights to. And what the hell is wrong with Canada?”
Matt’s Review:
I remember it well – about 16 years ago – when I first heard Cannibal Corpse’s cover of Black Sabbath’s “Zero The Hero.” Even though I had been a Sabbath fan for quite some time (yes, even Ian Gillian-era), I had just started venturing into death and grindcore territory, as far as expanding my metal horizons was concerned. Regardless, I was still a green teenage musical whore and it didn’t take much for something to seduce my inner ear canals at that point, as long as it was heavy. Needless to say, what can potentially be a very good thing can also be a very baaaaaad thing. How else would you explain my brief love for Nuclear Assault? Anyways, back to the point… I loved the first minute of the song. It was heavier and doomier than the original. Then the vocals came in. That’s it. That’s the end of my story.
Oh, I’ll just cut the crap already – I’ve never cared much for Chris Barnes as a vocalist (or as a musician for that matter). Don’t get me wrong. I know that his vocal style inspired a lot of other tone-deaf dude-bros with no sense of melody to start gutter-growling into a microphone, and for that I have to at least give him SOME form of props. But like I said earlier, what can potentially be a good thing can actually be a giant shit sandwich exploding like an atomic bomb on a small country, radiating all sorts of shit-like deformities on everything and everyone it touches along the way. Oh wait, that was the long version. Sorry dude-bros, my bad…
After hearing the first two Graveyard Classics albums, I had a pretty good idea of what to expect on this one – heavier, down-tuned, unimaginative, pointlessly inferior versions of the originals with the same damn gutter-growling from start to finish. Regardless, I was determined to keep an open mind and give the ole’ Six Feet boys a completely unbiased critique… assuming that I would be able to make it through the entire album without pulling all of my pubes out one-by-one, that is… turns out my will was strong, so my pubes stayed intact.
The first track, Mercyful Fate’s “A Dangerous Meeting,” brought back the same memories of when I first heard “Zero The Hero.” I mean, what did I actually expect? Chris Barnes to start singing falsetto? Well maybe, but is it really that wrong for me to ask him to at least try not to sound like a total dipshit while singing someone else’s songs? Weh-hell-hell, apparently it is…
I got much of the same vibe on the second track, which is Anvil’s “Metal On Metal.” You know, there’s a reason why Anvil never ‘made it.’ They are simply a terrible band… and this is a terrible cover.
Now that brings us to track 3, Metallica’s “The Frayed Ends Of Sanity,” which also happens to be one of my favorite Met songs ever. I must say, the rhythm tracks are pretty solid, but the solo is pretty damn sloppy and ruins it all for me. This doesn’t make much sense since, well, the solo IS overdubbed and it IS possible to re-record it if it’s played shitty. On the brighter side, Gall is a better drummer than Lars.
Slayer’s “At Dawn They Sleep” is actually one of the better covers on the album, in my opinion. Sure, it’s nowhere near as good as the original, but it somehow suits them well. Don’t ask me why. Oh, and Gall’s fill at the end isn’t bad either.
BTO’s “Not Fragile” just plain sucks. Bad choice. Very bad choice.
Oh yeah, the same goes for Van Halen’s “On Fire” and Exciter’s “Pounding Metal.“ On a roll, boys. On a roll.
Until now… they actually redeem themselves with Twisted Sister’s “Destroyer.“ It might be the only song on the album that actually sounds like it could be an original. For me, it translates pretty well… although I’m not totally convinced that J.J. French (or even Dee for that matter) would be proud to hear this.
“Psychotherapy” by the Ramones is pretty hard to butcher completely since, well, it is punk after all. As someone I played it for told me, it “sounds like Cookie Monster does the Ramones.” I can just picture that Sesame Street episode right now - a bunch of little kids are dancing around like idiots while the Cookie Monster hardcore dances and growls into a microphone… where were these episodes when I was a kid???
I can’t really say that they end with a bang, but “Snap Your Fingers, Snap Your Neck” isn’t too bad. They do a decent job with the music, I think. However, it’s another one of those songs where it doesn’t really matter how the vocals sound because the original ones weren’t that great to begin with (sorry Tommy, I didn’t mean to bring you into this).
All in all, that makes about 3 somewhat listenable covers on this entire album, which isn’t exactly good since that also means they’ve managed to successfully botch the other 7 songs, in my opinion. At this rate, there’s no reason to believe that this shit storm will stop, especially since this is already their third installment. Hmmm… something tells me that they enjoy pissing on amputated legs.
Matt’s Rating:
King says: “Fuck these guys… they broke the oath.”
Have A Listen:
Six Feet Under – A Dangerous Meeting:
Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.