Justin’s Review:

This day in age, it’s almost pointless to continue referring to Nachtmystium as a Black Metal band. The former troo kvlt USBM stalwarts have shed so much or their corpse-painted stigma, one almost forgets that less that six years ago Blake Judd was ball deep “bringing some of the world’s most extreme music to the world’s most extreme audiences.” with Battle Kommand Records. But throughout the numerous stylistic and lineup changes, there’s one BM trait Nachtmystium still hold near and dear to their hearts… pissing off the majority of people who loved their previous record.

Lucky for them, I’m not one of those people. Over the course of the last four years, Nachtmystium has declared “fuck you” to what was expected of them and delivered compelling album after compelling album. 2006’s Instinct: Decay scratched the surface (and no doubt left fans scratching their heads) by introducing a variety of psychedelic elements and soundscapes to the standard black metal fare. Then, in 2008, Assassins comes along with it’s blatant Pink Floyd worship, and begged the question… who exactly are these guys trying to impress? Three songs into Addicts, and that answer is clear… themselves.

It takes some seriously big balls (or seriously good drugs) for a band who’s name means “Encompassing Darkness” to write, record and release a song like Nightfall. I’m having a tough time even describing it… but the terms 80s/dance/pop all come to mind. The next track, No Funeral, follows suit with its jarring (yet shockingly appropriate) synth line and 80s snare sound. The title track continues the overall theme by showcasing the band’s best Killing Joke impression. And while we get back to “metal” territory with the next couple tracks (Blood Trance Fusion being my favorite Nactmystium song thus far), things once again return to the club scene with Ruined Life Continuum. It boggles my mind that Wrest, the same guy who brought us “Massive Conspiracy Against All Life” can now be found playing avant-garde dance beats. What a strange world we live in.

In full, Addicts is not nearly as thorough or cohesive as Assassins, but after repeated listens… it all begins to somehow make sense. Whether that was the intention or just mere coincidence remains to be seen. What I can safely say, is I expect to see Addicts appearing on plenty “best of” and “worst of” 2010 lists.

While most anyone not affiliated with “hipster metal” will continue to cry “bullshit sellouts,” the fact remains that Nachtmystium are successfully doing what few bands dare attempt… reinventing themselves.

And to some degree… the metal landscape at the same time.

Justin’s Rating:

King says: “This album keeps getting better every time I hear it. Too bad I can’t say the same for my falsetto!”

Mark’s Review:

I’ve written this review a few times now and I’m through rationalizing. I wanted to write a review on how confused I was and how hard it is to describe the new album by Nachmystium, Addicts: Black Meddle Part II. I was wondering if I truly liked it, just WANTED to like it, or hated it. Well, after many re-writes and re-listens, I really think I just don’t like this album and no amount of deep introspection into Blake Judd’s vision or acceptance of Gothic trance music will change that. Nachtmystium is definitely forging into new directions and deciding that the band will boldly go wherever they please musically. While this is a commendable stance, it always runs the risk of alienating a fanbase for the sake of personal gratification. I guess I don’t feel alienated, I’ve just become disinterested… which is maybe worse.

I don’t want to be so close-minded, but I there’s just not enough on Addicts to suck me in. The songs really aren’t terrible (in fact, High on Hate, Nightfall and Then Fires are pretty good), but the lack of attention paid to the details slowly becomes annoying. From the lazy vocal-phrasing and lyrics to the dull, repetitive passages that plague almost every song, everything has a disjointed and “half-assed” feel. So basically I’m left with two interpretations:

    1) either this is a very high-concept work of art that I cannot fully grasp, or
    2) it’s an incomplete and unfinished batch of songs given high importance by pretentious music blogs and hype

Either way, I don’t feel like I will be frequently listening to this album in the future. It’s not really a testament to the quality of the music, just a personal disconnect with the style and presentation. Now if you’ll please excuse me, I’m going to get back to blasting Hell Bent for Leather…

Mark’s Rating:

King says: “Blake… how come you never wear the makeup anymore??”

Have A Listen:

Nachtmystium – No Funeral:

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.